WIKI TWITTER YOUTUBE BLOG FLICKR
ABOUT
Planeta.com
''

search the planet


 

Last Updated



PLANETA FEATURE

Lines in the Water
a review by Ron Mader

WATER FORUM
WATER NOTEBOOK

Lines in the Water (University of California Press, 2002, 287 pages, $20) is a beautifully written ethnography of rural fishermen and their families.


FLICKR ALBUM: Water
SLIDESHOW


Subtitled "Nature and Culture at Lake Titicaca" this book boasts a broad stroak and it's difficult to find the appropriate works to say how delightful it is and why we recommend it so highly.


Book

Author Ben Orlove is an environmental science professor at the University of California, Davis, and his book is based on three decades of trips to Peru and Bolivia. The book is showcases fresh writing and is a major contribution to the literature about South America.

Orlove provides a frank account of the role academics play in development and conservation circles abroad. He includes himself in this story and shares candid observations -- from his reactions to office politics in Peru to daydreaming about museums on the edge of the lake.

Eco travelers visiting the region would do well to read this book in advance. This book is highly recommended.


Excerpts from Lines in the Water:

I was about to go out the front door, catch a bus and begin my rounds of appointments, when I saw Dora, the maid, standing in the entryway near a table with the telephone. "Excuse me, does the telephone work in Aymara?" she called to Phil, who was in the next room ... It was only as I walked down the hill that I recalled her question and began to reflect on it. It struck me as funny. How could anyone think that the telephone would not work in Aymara? (p. 63)

As lines on the land along which people walk, paths have a material existence. Their physicality and their unbreakable association with movement and travel allow them to stand for other, less tangible lines and movement. One can think of metaphorical paths as lines through time rather than space: paths as sequences, not as places, or more precisely, not only of places, but of the events and phases that mark an individual's life. (p. 210).

More than 150 villages line the shores of Lake Titicaca. No two have identical landscapes. (p. 173).

In geological terms, lakes are ephemeral. It is not much of an exaggeration to compare them to puddles that disappear soon after they form ... The age that is required for a lake to be termed "ancient" is only a few hundred thousand years -- an age at which a river would still be in its youth and a mountain range in its infancy. (p. 41)

It seemed to me that the workshop had contained many moments that demeaned the fishermen. We had been treating them as if they were uneducated boors, strangers in the world of government agencies, printed forms and standard measures. In the gratitude with which the fishermen accepted a few sandwiches, in their hesitation to ask questions, I sensed an acceptance of this assumed inferiority. And yet the fishermen were also in some sense being honored by their inclusion in the project. As I write now, I view all the documentation -- the notebooks and forms, the registration of the survey fishermen, the diplomas that would be granted -- more broadly. It represents not merely a chance for the fishermen to earn some money, but also an opportunity to garner recognition for themselves, for their villages, for their entire way of life. In the patience with which the fishermen waited to be registered, I see an element of their commitment not to be forgotten, a step in the fight against oblivion. (pp. 83-84)


BIBLIOGRAPHIES: Ecotourism | Environment | Latin America | Mexico | US/Mexico Border | The Maya | Central America | Caribbean | South America | The World | Spirituality | Business | Web Books



PLANETA


UPGRADE YOUR WORLD

Upgrade your world! See if Ron's workshop works for you.

www.flickr.com
 

seminars





events

mtw

GOOGLE
NEWS


 

 

 


Copyright © 1994-2012. All rights reserved by individual authors. Link Guidelines