WIKI FORUM VIDEOS WORKSHOPS PHOTOS
ABOUT
Planeta.com
'

SEARCH THIS SITE


 

Last Updated


PLANETA FEATURE

Second Creation (Review)
by Ron Mader

Recommended.

www.flickr.com


PHOTO GALLERY: Favorites


After the 1776 revolution, the citizens of the United States of America began to reimagine themselves and their country. The founders of the United States conceived of the nation as a second creation that could only improve on God's handiwork. European-Americans justified their claim on the land through stories in which the central role was played by various technologies, in particular the axe, the mill, the canal, the railroad and the dam.


Marginalized groups told different stories, focusing on destruction and loss. Indigenous people protested the loss of their forests, and fishermen resisted the construction of dams. To explore these contradictions, author David Nye devotes alternating chapters to the stories of second creation and to the stories of those who rejected it in his new book America as Second Creation: Technology and Narratives of New Beginnings (MIT Press, 2003, 371 pages, $30)

Book

Nye, a professor of American Studies at Denmark's Syddansk University, draws on a plethora of historical documents as well as literary and cinematic sources. This book can be read on its own or with Nye's other work that began with American Techological Sublime and continued with Consuming Power.

Nye quotes a select list of thinkers from Henry David Thoreau to John Steinbeck. The only critique I have of the documentation is that the bibliography only includes the scholarly references. A list of films, paintings and literature would be helpful.

A number of pictures and drawings from the U.S. Library of Congress. He explains how the technological foundation narratives and counter-narratives challenged the dominant ideology. The result is a fascinating analysis. Nye suggests that a creative society could use new technologies as means of achieving sustainable development but only when citizens "embrace new stories that move beyond second creation." (p. 302)

 

Excerpts from America as Second Creation

When Europeans invaded the edges of the newly discovered continent of North America, the stories they told to make sense of their world came from their homelands In popular literature, speeches, advertisements, paintings and many other forms, European-Americans invented foundation stories as they entered new regions of North America and used powerful technologies to transform these spaces into familiar landscapes. (pp. 1-2)

Native Americans' stories of origin provide an instructive counterpoint to those of European-Americans. Native Americans' stories express their sense of oneness with the land. The first people are said to have emerged out of the earth or to have come into the world through the intervention of spiritual beings. (p. 2)

By the 1970s, log houses had become a "lifestyle" choice. More than 10,000 were built each year, many of them assembled from pre-cut kits with numbered parts ö With the mass production of pre-cut logs for easy assembly, the narrative of the log cabin reached the point of logical self-contradiction. Not only had the machine displaced human muscle power, but the purpose of the structure itself was no longer shelter from the wilderness. Its purpose now was escape from civilization. (pp. 83-84)

Railroads remain a vital part of the American transportation network. In 1990, freight trains still carried more than trucks, even though 90,000 miles of track had disappeared since 1920. Yet because American railways carry so few passengers, they exist at the margins of public consciousness. Some of the great passenger stations, like those in Omaha and Kansas City, long stood unused and empty. Others have been torn down. In Washington and Indianapolis the central stations have been converted to shopping malls. (p. 203)

Norris, Muir and others of the Progressive Era who attacked the railroads for their selfish pursuit of wealth and power were writing in the tradition of what Sacvan Bercovitch has called the "American jeremiad." The railroad's original promise that it would foster development and democracy was followed by its "declension" or spectacular failure to fulfill its social mission. The railroad had stimulated wasteful land speculation, created ghost towns, undermined and destroyed existing communities And yet the railroad might still serve its original purpose if it were better regulated (or owned) by the state. Thus the critique of the railroad often ended in a hopeful prophecy of what it could be in the future. (p. 195)

One could imagine the settlement of the United States from the viewpoint of animals. Jim O'Brien's often-reprinted essay "A Beaver's Perspective on North American History" begins before any humans had arrived. Beavers dammed streams, created small canals and ponds and reshaped the landscape in ways that affected the larger biotic community. The beaver population, which may have reached 60 million at its height, went into decline with the arrival of the European fur trade. O'Brien's narrative radically reconsiders American history as a catastrophe. (p. 298)



PLANETA


SEMINARS

Learning never ends. See if one of our workshops is right for you.

www.flickr.com
 


seminars



events

mtw

GOOGLE
NEWS


WEB SEMINAR

Tips for Authors
and Publishers

 

TA

 

 


Copyright © 1994-2008. All rights reserved by individual authors. Link Guidelines